Back to Gallery
Public Decision

My girlfriend cheated on me, should I forgive her or break up?

10/7/2025
4 options analyzed

AI VERDICT

Breaking up allows you to prioritize your well-being and avoid potential long-term health consequences associated with infidelity.

Recommended Choice

Break Up: End the relationship immediately and begin the process of moving on. This involves cutting off contact, seeking support from friends and family, and focusing on personal healing and growth. This is a clean break focused on self-preservation and avoiding further potential hurt.

Score:75/100
Risk:low
Rank:#1

Why This Choice?

Testimonials show that infidelity can lead to lasting emotional and physical harm, even in future relationships. A clean break allows for self-preservation and focused healing, preventing further hurt and enabling a healthier future.

Next Steps

  • 1Cut off contact
  • 2Seek support from friends and family
  • 3Focus on personal growth and healing
A
Recommended

Break Up: End the relationship immediately and begin the process of moving on. This involves cutting off contact, seeking support from friends and family, and focusing on personal healing and growth. This is a clean break focused on self-preservation and avoiding further potential hurt.

75/100
low Risk

Key Factors

cost70%
risk level20%
feasibility90%
time to results60%
long term benefit85%

Pros

  • • Avoids potential for future hurt
  • • Opportunity for personal growth
  • • Clean break allows faster healing
  • • Rebuild trust with someone new

Cons

  • • Painful initial separation period
  • • Loss of shared history/memories
  • • May regret the decision later
B

Open and Honest Discussion with No Immediate Decision: Communicate your feelings of hurt, betrayal, and anger. Ask her to explain her actions and motivations without interruption. Focus on understanding the 'why' behind the infidelity. Then, take a few days (or a week) of space to process the information and consider your options without pressure. After this period, revisit the conversation and decide on a course of action (breakup, conditional forgiveness, or further discussion).

75/100
medium Risk

Key Factors

cost95%
risk level50%
feasibility85%
time to results60%
long term benefit80%

Pros

  • • Understanding the situation is possible
  • • Potential for healing and reconciliation
  • • Avoids rash decisions, promotes calm

Cons

  • • Emotional pain can be prolonged
  • • No guarantee of truthful answers
  • • Requires emotional strength and vulnerability
C

Conditional Forgiveness with Therapy: Express your hurt and anger, but state that you are willing to consider forgiveness *only* if your girlfriend agrees to individual therapy to address the underlying reasons for the infidelity, and couples therapy to rebuild trust and communication. This involves setting clear boundaries, expectations for transparency, and a timeline for assessing progress. Re-evaluate the relationship after a defined period (e.g., 6 months) based on demonstrable effort and improvement.

65/100
medium Risk

Key Factors

cost50%
risk level60%
feasibility70%
time to results40%
long term benefit80%

Pros

  • • Potential for reconciliation and growth
  • • Addresses underlying issues
  • • Rebuilds trust and communication skills
  • • Sets clear boundaries and expectations

Cons

  • • Therapy can be expensive and time-consuming
  • • No guarantee of success
  • • Requires significant emotional investment
  • • May prolong pain if unsuccessful
D

Trial Separation with Focused Communication: Suggest a temporary separation (e.g., one month) to gain perspective and evaluate your feelings independently. During this time, both of you should refrain from dating other people but commit to honest and open communication about your individual needs, expectations, and whether or not you believe the relationship can be salvaged. At the end of the separation, reassess your feelings and make a final decision.

65/100
medium Risk

Key Factors

cost90%
risk level50%
feasibility75%
time to results70%
long term benefit60%

Pros

  • • Time to process feelings independently
  • • Opportunity for honest communication
  • • Clarifies individual needs and expectations
  • • Potentially rebuild trust slowly

Cons

  • • Separation could increase distance
  • • Honest communication can be painful
  • • No guarantee of reconciliation
  • • Emotional distress during separation

Community Insights

Being cheated on by a romantic partner can potentially harm your long-term health. People who have experienced partner infidelity are more likely to report worse chronic health, and this effect persists even when they are in other supportive relationships.

— Anonymous

When I found out, I went crazy. I can honestly empathize with people who do irrational shit when they find out they’ve been cheated on because betrayal is painful especially when it’s undeserved.

— Anonymous

I’ve been cheated on long story short (18 years of marriage see other posts) and it’s been 5 months since finding out before IVF egg retrieval the AP was pregnant with my husband.

— Anonymous

70% typically stay and try to work it out after an affair.

— Anonymous

Infidelity is a deeply painful and disorienting experience that often leaves spouses questioning the future of their relationship.

— Anonymous

She's fooled you once by having you “forgive” her one time already. But to go back and fool around on you a second time,

— Anonymous

My spouse had an emotional affair that went on for 3 months.

— Anonymous

Success Rate Analysis

Analysis Statistics

4
Options Analyzed
75%
Confidence Level
1
Low Risk Options
75
Highest Score

Need Help with Your Own Decision?

Get AI-powered analysis for your choices in minutes. Join thousands of others making better decisions.

Analyze Your Decision